Cold In July – directed by Jim Mickle. Thriller. 109 minutes Color 2014.
★★★
The Story: A small town merchant kills a housebreaker in his home and there are many consequences.
~
Why doesn’t it wash?
We have four wonderfully skilled and properly chosen actors to perform it, Nick Damici, Michael C. Hall, Don Johnson, and Sam Shepard. They all give tremendous value, and one of the problems might be the focus on that value. For the director has allowed each of them the time to reveal themselves in normal fashion in circumstances which are not normal at all. Has he turned, or tried to turn, the instruments of a Thriller into the personnel of a Tragedy?
And if all this is true, why is the part of the wife a thankless role? Because it’s not well written, that’s why. It refuses to set the wife in anything but TV-acting opposition to the practices of her husband. Instead she whines or gathers her youngster up from the restaurant and walks out. Or canoodles. She is never allowed to be intensely interested in him as a human being. She is never allowed to try to see through him. Or she hasn’t the imagination to do so.
The piece begins in a bloodbath and, of course, ends in one. And very good blood baths they are too. But between them, all I see is circumstances that would play very well in a novel. In a novel you must imagine what you are told, so the focus of your imagination screens off the improbable. In a movie everything’s right there in front of your eyes, and imagination is fatal. In a novel you can’t see the anomalies.
You can’t see that those men’s leaving that drugged ex-con on the railroad tracks is sure to lead back to them.
You can’t believe that in the dead of night with headlights ablaze a car could follow two other cars out into the country without those other cars tumbling to it.
You can’t believe that the FBI would permit the occupants of a safe house the liberty to consistently make snuff porn.
The secret of a Thriller is that the emotion shown has to be so tight and constricted in its range that you are never allowed to look elsewhere in your mind for human inconstancy.
But these four men’s performances are full of human inconstancy. They are beautiful performances. They are Oscar worthy performances.
But do they belong in a Thriller?